China: Change Or Crisis
Mon October 29, 2012
China's New Leaders Inherit Country At A Crossroads
Originally published on Tue October 30, 2012 10:53 am
China is about to get new leaders for the first time in a decade, and it comes at a sensitive moment for the world's most populous nation. Economic growth, which surged for decades, has slowed. Demands for political reform have increased and the Communist Party has been hit by scandal. In a series of stories this week, NPR is examining the multiple challenges facing China. In our first story, Louisa Lim looks at how the Chinese view the Communist Party in the place where it took shape.
History is little more than a commodity in Yan'an, the town in western China that markets itself as the "Holy Land of China's Communist Revolution." The former revolutionary base of Chairman Mao Zedong is a place that encapsulates the strange ideological contortions China's Communist Party has twisted itself into over the past 63 years.
Mao and his comrades hid in the hillside caves of Yan'an in Shaanxi province for 13 years beginning in the 1930s, as they tried to build rural support for a communist revolution.
For Chinese businessman Yang Xiaowu, visiting Yan'an is his idea of a corporate team-building exercise. A fervent party supporter who works as an alcohol distributor, Yang has traveled 185 miles to Yan'an from the provincial capital of Xi'an more than 10 times, bringing employees and clients each time.
"We came here to learn revolutionary spirit and to understand our history," he says. "It helps us a lot in doing business and marketing."
These days, though, all eyes are on the future. Next week, China begins a once-in-a-decade transition of power, as leaders grapple with a damaging political scandal involving murder and corruption that has left the Communist Party reeling.
The world is awaiting the formal ascension of Xi Jinping to general secretary, the top Communist Party post; he is also tapped to become the country's next president in March. The spotlight is also on Li Keqiang, slated to be the next prime minister, along with the other members of the all-powerful committee that forms the country's collective leadership.
But with calls for reform mounting in the run-up to the 18th Party Congress meeting, has China's political model reached its limits?
Cashing In On Revolution
Not so, say people like Yang, the alcohol distributor. On a recent morning in Yan'an, he and his team are enthusiastically watching the re-creation of a 1947 Chinese Civil War battle between the Communists and their Nationalist enemies. Every morning at 11 sharp, gunshots blaze on all sides, and a burning plane zooms down a zip wire.
Yang has even paid extra for some of his staff members to take part in the battle on the side of the losing, mustard-suited Nationalists. When a Chairman Mao lookalike appears to make a stump speech, the crowd roars happily.
For Yang, Mao's works offer useful management advice for dealing with competitors.
"Mao's piece 'On Protracted War' is the basic ideological guide we use for our alcohol business," he says. "We learn and carry forward revolutionary Yan'an spirit, and combine it with our culture of drinking, to make our alcohol business big and strong."
The local government in Yan'an is cashing in on its revolutionary history as well. It built a cavernous $80 million Revolutionary Memorial Hall in 2009 and recently launched a new $5.5 million song-and-dance spectacular. Tourist numbers have tripled in five years to 20 million visitors in 2011, bringing $1.75 billion in revenues.
'The Road We Chose Was Wrong'
Even in Yan'an, where Chairman Mao and the early revolutionaries huddled in their chilly caves, penning essays explicating the party's ideology, few visitors notice the party's U-turns.
These are in plain view, however, in the dusty meeting halls where 1940s banners hanging from the ceiling call for the early adoption of democracy. Few know, or remember, that Mao himself advocated multiparty democracy, a position he abandoned after gaining power.
But there are survivors from those days who have not forgotten why they waged revolution.
"Our purpose was to achieve freedom and democracy," remembers 90-year-old revolutionary He Fang. "But now there is neither freedom nor democracy. The road we chose was wrong."
At age 15, He ran away to join the Communists, and helped dig out the caves tourists now frequent. In the 1950s, He rose high in the party as secretary to Zhang Wentian, deputy foreign minister. He then fell far — together with his boss, who had criticized aspects of Mao's Great Leap Forward campaign in the late-'50s. He was sent to do hard labor in the countryside for 19 years.
He is critical of Chairman Mao, who he says "had a temper like a child" and treated China like a toy that could be tossed around.
The straight-talking He is also bluntly critical of today's Communist Party.
"The Communist Party wants to realize communism, but no one today knows what communism is," he says.
A Crisis Of Faith
Such sentiments would seem like heresy in Yan'an, where groups of young party members wait in line to swear oaths of allegiance to the party, fists clenched by their heads, on a pagoda-topped hill overlooking the town.
But even inside the temples of communism — the party schools training the elite — people are worrying about a crisis of faith.
Wang Binglin, a professor at one of these schools in Beijing, addresses the issue head-on during a recent lecture.
"Each religion has followers. You cannot achieve anything without followers. Do we have followers? We have 80 million party members," Wang tells a group of social science academics, as he parses the differences between religious believers and party members.
"We are short of nothing. But why are we not that devout?" he says. "The main reason lies in ... the extent to which we worship and believe in our [communist] classics. Some people don't believe them. Some don't even read them."
For many party members, faith in China's Communist Party died in Tiananmen Square, when the army opened fire on unarmed protesters in 1989.
From then on, political reform was off-limits. The unspoken contract was that the party would bring economic change to the people, and indeed, it has lifted hundreds of millions out of poverty. But the gap between rich and poor has widened into a chasm, and even China's Academy of Social Sciences warns of a potential public crisis if no reforms are made.
Wage Gap Widens
The Chinese Communist Party was supposed to be the party of workers and peasants, but 63 years of communist rule has not changed life substantially for peasants near Yan'an. They still lead subsistence existences in damp caves carved out of the hillside, the walls plastered with old advertisements for warmth.
"City folk definitely live and eat and do everything better than us," says Guo Haiyun, limping across the yard of his cave home, close to Yan'an. "Of course I envy them."
For him, the privileges enjoyed by city dwellers — like subsidized medical care and social welfare — are a pipe dream.
A frail 46-year-old, Guo was a migrant worker, building China's economic miracle, until he was injured. Now he survives on an allowance given to the disabled.
"The Communist Party is good," he enthuses. "Life is much better than it was 20 years ago."
But simple questions elicit a more troubling reality: The family has been heavily driven into debt to fund his daughter's university education. His son has even sacrificed his own education for a banal reality of washing cars to pay for his sister's future.
"I can't return it," Guo says of his $3,000 debt. "How can we save? I have no money. Probably I only have two or three yuan at home."
China's urban dwellers earn on average 3.22 times more than its rural dwellers, and that gap is expected to widen further.
Scandal A Symbol Of The Party's Problems
Such rural poverty is harder to bear, knowing China's elite are enriching themselves, using an unholy alliance of patronage and power.
An object lesson in the use of power has come with the downfall of powerful politician Bo Xilai. Until March, Bo was Communist Party secretary of the city of Chongqing.
Now, he faces criminal investigations into abuse of power, corruption, improper relationships with women and involvement in murder. His wife, Gu Kailai, also known as Bogu Kailai, is serving a suspended death sentence, after being found guilty of the 2011 murder of British businessman Neil Heywood. Bloomberg has reported that her sisters control a business empire worth $126 million.
Bo is the son of a revolutionary hero, a creature of the party. According to one former insider, he symbolizes all that's wrong with the party.
"If the father becomes an emperor, the son must become an emperor, too," says former official Bao Tong. "That's socialism with Chinese characteristics. It's false socialism. It's about keeping their power. The guiding principle is: I must have power, I must be an official, I must be corrupt and lawless. This is the Chinese model."
Bao was once secretary to Zhao Ziyang, the reformist party boss who sympathized with the protesters in 1989. Now 79 years old, Bao despairs over the fiefdoms of power that have been carved out under the current system.
"It may be worse than the feudal era. Then, when the emperor found a landlord bullying people, he could put him on trial," Bao says. "Now there's not just one landlord in each village, there's at least 10, including the village head, the party secretary, their deputies and their predecessors."
Popular Discontent Rising
Amid a rising tide of scandals involving corrupt party members, public anger is widespread. Even at one communist pilgrimage spot, Chairman Mao's cave in Yan'an, a visitor who gives his name as Mr. Su says he believes all officials are corrupt.
"Now there are 80 million Communist Party members. I think half of them should be killed," Su says. "If every official serving at county level or above was shot by a firing squad, I don't think any innocent blood would be shed."
Mao's Communists prided themselves on their discipline, as they stood against the corruption of the Nationalists. Now, China's new leaders have to act fast. The dividends of double-digit growth are over, but they've enriched a princeling class — the descendants of old revolutionary heroes of which Bo and the incoming president, Xi, is a member — whose vast wealth and influence have turned them into the new emperors, representing what the party once opposed.
ROBERT SIEGEL, HOST:
From NPR News, this is ALL THINGS CONSIDERED. I'm Robert Siegel.
AUDIE CORNISH, HOST:
And I'm Audie Cornish. Next week, China begins a sweeping once-in-a-decade transition of power. The moves comes as its Communist leaders grapple with the scandal that paints a damaging picture of their party: corrupt, nepotistic and ruthless. All this week, we'll be reporting on China's big transition and whether the Chinese model, both political and economic, has reached its limits. Today, we focus on the political and on rising disillusionment with the Communist Party inside China. Here is NPR's Louisa Lim.
LOUISA LIM, BYLINE: China's Communists still wage war against their Nationalist enemies at 11 o'clock every morning for the tourist hordes. This is the old Communist stronghold of Yan'an, where Chairman Mao lived for 13 years starting in the '30s. Now, every morning gunshots blaze as a battle from 1947 is recreated.
UNIDENTIFIED WOMAN #1: An actor playing Chairman Mao has just come out, and everybody is clapping him.
LIM: This is history as spectacle. Yang Xiaowu, an alcohol distributor, has brought his employees here.
YANG XIAOWU: (Speaking foreign language)
LIM: We come here to learn revolutionary sprit, he says. It helps us sell booze. And Yan'an today is all about the commodification of China's Communist past.
UNIDENTIFIED WOMAN #2: (Speaking foreign language)
LIM: Even here, few noticed the party's U-turns. But they're in plain view. Banners from the 1940s call for democracy. Even Chairman Mao advocated multi-party democracy, a position he abandoned after gaining power. Some have not forgotten, like 90-year-old revolutionary He Fang.
HE FANG: (Through Translator) Our purpose was to achieve freedom and democracy. But now, there is neither freedom nor democracy. The road we chose was wrong.
LIM: He Fang ran away aged 15 to join the Communists. He dug those caves now visited by tourists out of the hillside. He rose high in the party, then fell far and was exiled to the country for 19 years. He is critical of Chairman Mao. Mao, he says, had a temper like a child and treated China like a toy that could be tossed around. He's critical too of today's party.
FANG: (Through Translator) The Communist Party wants to realize communism, but no one today knows what communism is.
UNIDENTIFIED GROUP: (Speaking foreign language)
LIM: In Yan'an, young party members swear oaths of allegiance to the party. But inside its temples, the party schools training the elite, they worry about a crisis of faith.
UNIDENTIFIED MAN #1: (Speaking foreign language)
UNIDENTIFIED MAN #2: (Speaking foreign language)
LIM: At Beijing party school, Professor Wang Binglin is addressing this head on. He's lecturing on why China's Communists aren't as devout as religious believers. Some party members don't believe the Communist classics, he admits. Some don't even read them.
UNIDENTIFIED MAN #3: (Speaking foreign language)
(SOUNDBITE OF GUNFIRE)
LIM: For many, faith in the Communist Party died in Tiananmen Square when the army opened fire on unarmed protesters in 1989. From then on, political reform was off limits. The unspoken contract was that the party would bring economic change to the people. It has lifted hundreds of millions out of poverty. But the gap between rich and poor has widened into a chasm. That idea, far from the Communist ideal of equality, has become engrained. The Communist Party was supposed to be the party of workers and peasants, but now city dwellers enjoy privileges like subsidized medical care and social welfare that farmers can only dream of.
GUO HAIYUN: (Through Translator) City folk definitely live and eat and do everything better than us. Of course, I envy them.
LIM: That's Guo Haiyun. He lives across the yard of his cave home close to the revolutionary base in Yan'an. He was injured as a migrant worker and survives on an allowance given to the disabled. He's a big supporter of the Communist Party. But with one child at university, he barely gets by.
HAIYUN: (Through Translator) I borrowed money for several years for my daughter's education, and I can't return it. Probably I have only two or $3 at home.
LIM: Today, such rural poverty is harder to bear, knowing the elite are enriching themselves using an unholy alliance of patronage and power. Bao Tong was once an insider, secretary to Zhao Ziyang, the reformist party boss who sympathized with the protesters in 1989.
ZHAO ZIYANG: (Through Translator) Bao met me in a noisy fast food restaurant in Beijing. Seventy-nine years old, he lives under surveillance after spending seven years in prison after Tiananmen Square. He's despairing about China's current situation.
(Through Translator) It may be worse than the feudal era. Then, when the emperor found a landlord bullying people, he could put them on trial. Now there's not just one landlord in each village. There's at least 10, including the village head, the party secretary, their deputies and their predecessors.
UNIDENTIFIED WOMAN #3: (Speaking foreign language)
LIM: Fiefdoms of power are being carved out. This was clear in this bombshell moment. State television announcing the powerful politician Bo Xilai faces criminal charges possibly including abuse of power, corruption and involvement in covering up a murder. His wife's already been found guilty of killing a British businessman over a business deal gone wrong. Bo is the son of a revolutionary hero, a creature of the party. Bao Tong believes he symbolizes all that's wrong with it.
BAO TONG: (Through Translator) If the father becomes an emperor, the son must become an emperor too. That's socialism with Chinese characteristics. It's false socialism. It's about keeping their power. The guiding principle is: I must have power. I must be an official. I must be corrupt and lawless. This is the Chinese model.
LIM: Such cynicism is widespread. At one Communist pilgrimage spot, Chairman Mao's cave in Yan'an, a man who gives his name as Mr. Su says he believes all officials are corrupt.
SU: (Through Translator) If every official serving at county level or above was shot by a firing squad, I don't think any innocent blood would be shed.
UNIDENTIFIED GROUP: (Singing in foreign language)
LIM: Communist songs echo throughout this revolutionary base. Mao's Communists prided themselves on their discipline, standing against the corruption of the Nationalists. Now, China's new leaders have to act fast. The dividends of double-digit growth are over, but they've enriched a princeling class, whose vast wealth and influence has turned them into the new emperors representing all the party once opposed. China's Communist Party is no longer communist. Even its name is a big lie. And those double standards are chipping away at its legitimacy day after day. Louisa Lim, NPR News, Beijing.
UNIDENTIFIED GROUP: (Singing in foreign language) Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.